QUOTE(katefan4 @ Jul 3 2008, 10:00 PM) [snapback]134731[/snapback]
^You're right on Suzanne-I think I meant to say that she was somebody I admire from more folky-acoustic roots. I'm actually really picky on "singer/songwriters"-I've just seen too many terrible people who thought they were talented. She has a real stage presence quite a few singer/songwriters lack. I'm sorry so many younger folk seem to just know her through "Luka"-she has an amazing body of work.
You know, WLY, I am actually feeling like I am still even beginning to process the 90's...I was there (and played a very active role), BUT I have such little affection for a great deal from that period-even things I sort've liked during the period. Frankly, most of the people I loved & still love/collect on from the 90's-folk who are identifed as 90's (Garbage, Tori, No Doubt, etc.)- always wore their "I grew up in the 80's alternative" badges clearly marked on their sleeves, so it's hard to classify them with a lot of the movements of the 90's.
I totally agree with you on Sinead (and some folk before her) as being much more of a prototype & role model for angry women than most of the 90's folks. She was much more bold & defiant to the point it ruined her mainstream career. But, as Sinead always pointed out, she wanted to be a protest singer-not a pop star. In a sense, she stayed true to her word.
I think Phair was much more introspective than defiantly "angry"-I think she spoke for a lot of "nice" (I mean that as the ugly stereotype it is for a lot of smart, kind, sensitive people) young people, especially women, who grew up in the burbs & were taught to be "perfect" & polite and not say words like c*ck & c*nt-I think Liz even hits on this herself in interviews-that she was considered the "practically perfect child" who wrote her bizarre ditties as entertainment & release from her environment. I honestly can't think of Liz Phair as being an "angry woman" in the way Sinead, Patti Smith, Siouxsie, Exene, etc. were, but I think she filled an important void that was missing at that time.
you are dead on with singer songwriters. a lot of the current crop and the crop from the mid-late 80's to early 90's don't have the stage presence that suzanne had. and suzanne was the one that really jump started the whole movement of female singer songwriters during that time. i really didn't care for a lot of the lilth fair artists around. they all seemed cut from the same cloth and with little stage presence. it's sad that suzanne doesn't get near the respect she deserves and not a lot of her songs are bigger hits. though i would say she is more known for tom's diner than luka. she plays that as often if not more than luka. and they all sing along with her too. it's very surreal.
a lot of the 90's artists that were around and in the spotlight weren't really that great. not my cup of tea per se. for a lot of the same reasons that you mentioned. they tend to wear everything on their sleeve. they're as transparent as most politicians. the ones that stick out in my mind from the 90's are ones that were for the most part under the radar that shouldn't have been. the list includes patty griffin, fleming and john (although they had a minor hit), sister 7 (on the arista austin label), lode, the sundays (although they had some minor success), abra moore (also on the arista austin label. also had a minor hit.) aimee mann (also had some minor success), mary lou lord, kara's flowers, the evinrudes, and juliana hatfield. although hatfield killed her own success. most of those on that list (which is just a sampling) had some minor success, but they never really hit it big enough to be on the radar on the larger scope. liz phair could fit that bill as well, but she had more success.
i think as alternative became more corporate and more popular, the true alternative went underground again. one aritst though never really took off in the 90's only to came out again in the 00's to become big huge acts. kara's flowers is the band that did that. their debut the fourth world on reprise came and went in 1997.it soon went out of print. it was an fantastic slice of power pop that was so great. and they were so young too. soap disco was a geat song of the 90's. then the band came back in 2002 as maroon 5 and went on to become one of the biggest acts. their kara flowers debut was going for $40 dollars used since it was out of print. then in may of 2004 it was remastered and re-released on rhino. i think you need to dust off the 90's again and check out some of the more underrated under the radar artists i mentioned. there are some really great artists out there and some really great albums you need to hear.